![]() |
COMMENTS |
From Tim: As a vegetarian and a member of the VS for 20-odd years, I am constantly disappointed by the lack of profile we get. There are plenty of issues arising every day, one recent one being Dr Rajendra Pachauri, chair of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change recently saying that people should reduce their meat consumption even further to help reduce man-made climate change. Where was the immediate response from the VS?.... the VS expert pundit appearing on breakfast TV, in the press or Radio 4’s Today programme? Why was it not considered a priority to capitalise on this and other high-profile news stories? The same opportunities were missed during the BSE/CJD crisis, the Foot & Mouth crises etc etc. I do despair that our Society is not jumping on these chances - yes, in a reactive way perhaps, but who cares if it adds to the campaign? The media is shot through with successful pundits on other subjects who are sought after in times of a breaking story. These people get heard because they make it their business to be the first number that the programme producers, editors or journalists call for a comment. I want to feel there is that kind of campaigning passion in the VS, and I don’t. Instead I get cross when I hear everyone else’s point of view instead. Reply from Liz O'Neill, Head of Communications at the Vegetarian Society: Thanks for getting in touch and please accept my apologies for taking a few days to respond. I share your frustration that we don’t always have the public profile that we would like and that would make such a valuable contribution to raising the profile of vegetarianism. However, please be assured that this is not down to lack of effort or interest. I won’t claim that we follow up every possible lead, but we do have a very active press office and work hard to build relationships with key contacts all year round as well as responding to news stories as they break. Unfortunately that doesn’t always translate into reported interviews and much of the time we have contributed to the story, even if we don’t appear and aren’t quoted. Sometimes we even encourage press to interview representatives from other organizations because they are in a better position to say what needs to be said. The main reason for this last point is that, as an educational charity, we are the ‘safe’ face of vegetarianism and it’s better for the whole vegetarian movement that we retain that position while allowing others to offer the more radical view. One thing I would ask of you and, indeed all committed vegetarians, is to be an active consumer of the press. Write letters to the editor, contact the complaints line after poor TV reporting and generally make a fuss as comments from viewers, listeners and readers are often the most effective way of raising the profile of an issue, opening the door for us to get those interviews. I hope this goes some way to explaining our position and please don’t despair of us – although we may seem quiet at times, we really are all working for the same end result. From James: Honestly, leading a vegetarian or pescetarian diet (as I do) is scientifically proven to produce less Greenhouse gases; huge amounts of the energy contained in the Producer is lost as the energy moves further up the food chain. Even in the case of Pigs and Cows, who are Primary Consumers, this leads to a huge wastage of energy. Has everyone noticed why food prices are rising? One of the reasons is because many people, in countries such as China, are beginning to turn to a meat-based (as opposed to rice based) diet and thus the amount of crops is not going so far in feeding the people. Also huge swathes of the Amazon are being cut down to feed the growing (and already substantial) American demand for meat. I don't think there is anyway that Meat eaters can justify that eating a meat-based diet is doing no harm to the environment, or even begin to suggest that a vegetarian one does no better. From Cazza - vegetarian vs
carnivore: My husband is a carnivore but my daughter and
I have been vegetarians for over 15 years now. I buy and prepare
dinner
for us all but retain the hope that my husband will become vegetarian,
if only to make my life easier! The more I prepare meat etc the more
glad I am that I don't eat it. Whereas there is an energy in vegetables
(more so in organic ones) the meat or chicken is just dead and often
there is a smell, not because it is off but I think from the horror
of the killing process as well as the awful conditions. Even the
organically reared animals have a nasty time often. From Martin Allen: Surely the reason why meat production has gone by 100 tonnes since 1970 is due to the rise in population. Also mentioned in your article is deforestation to make way for ranches however if you stop to consider this statement then you reach a slight problem the main reason for deforestetion is to make way for large areas to grow palms and the like for bio-oils not for meat production. I'm not saying this is true in all areas but on the whole it is. As for the use of fossil fuels in meat production then if we sourced our meat locally rather than from the large supermarkets this would dramatically reduce the consumption of fuel even if you buy local produce from your supermarkets the likely hood is that it has travelled to a distrubution center miles and miles away only to come back to the store when it is only grown/produced around the corner. Whilst we are talking about fuel consumption surely the majority of manufactured fake meat e.g quorn mince etc uses far more fuel than say raising a chicken at home and slaughtering it yourself. Also the vegetarian diet relies heavily on other forms of protien from pulses and nuts to rices and beans most of which are not produced in this country but from abroad surely this uses far more fuel than production of meat from a local farm. In the article you also mentioned the gases from manure i'm guessing that this is the same manure that is used to grow organic vegetables, so allthough this manure is a by product of meat/dairy production it is used for other purposes not just as a waste material. From Steve Horton: I
have tried to get my head round your ad that appeared in Earth Matters.
It states that animal farming creates more greenhouse gases than
the worlds public transport system. From Linda Buss: Farm animal manure comes from digesting grass. If this then causes greenhouse gas emissions, what about the manure of wild animals that also eat grass? From John Sauven, Executive Director, Greenpeace UK: “Meat is the most inefficient way to use our land resources to produce food … choosing to cut out meat, buy locally and choose organic are all steps everyone can take to help save the climate.” From Jeanette Longfield MBE, Co-ordinator Sustain: the alliance for better food and farming: "If you eat meat or dairy products, make sure they come from high animal welfare systems and keep the quantities low. Evidence continues to accumulate that people who eat little or no meat and dairy products live healthier longer lives, and also reduce their impact on the environment - intensive livestock farming produces significant quantities of greenhouse gases as well as perpetuating poor treatment of sentient creatures." From Dr Caroline Lucas, Green Party MEP for South-East England, Vice-President of the European Parliament’s cross-party group on animal welfare, Green Group co-ordinator on the Parliament’s Climate Change Committee and Vice-President of the RSPCA: "It’s vital that, as a society, we eat less meat, both to cut emissions and out of respect for animal rights” In response to The Vegetarian Society's challenge
to go veggie for NVW
From Dr. Derek Wall, Green Party Principal Speaker: "To meet the challenge I am going to go vegan for a week and cut out dairy products. I have been a vegetarian for more than twenty years, reducing meat consumption reduces cruelty, the carbon footprint, is ecologically sound and healthy. I think everyone would benefit in a super sized world from cutting back and I am hoping other politicians take up the Vegetarian Socities challenge of giving up meat for a week. Curry, pasta, stir fry, Jamaican ital food and Morrocan are my favourite types of veggie food. I have never felt good about eating anything
with a face, it just dosn't feel right to me." I don't eat meat very often anyway, but hopefully going veggie will help me kick my habit once and for all. Going veggie is the greener lifestyle choice. Every time I choose not to eat meat, I will be choosing to reduce my carbon emissions - something we all need to think about." |
TIPS |
| Grow your own organic veg. No
matter what size garden you have, or how much spare time, there's always
something you can grow - ranging from herbs on a windowsill to a full
size veg patch! Homegrown veg cuts down on food miles, doesn't use harmful
pesticides and also tastes much nicer. To help get started have a look at
Garden
Organic, the National charity for organic growing.
Compost your waste: This is a great way to reduce rubbish in landfills, reduce the transport costs involved in refuse collection and at the same time gives you a great soil conditioner. A vegetarian diet really does mean that most things can be composted. To find out more have a look at the Community Composting Network Where's your food from?: Do you check labels and see if your food has been shipped half way across the world to make it's way to your plate. Checking to see where your food, as well as your wine, has come from can help reduce food miles and the related environmental impact. In a country where we can get any foods at any time of the year, a good tip is to eat seasonal fruit & veg as this is much more likely to be grown locally. |


